The Google homepages that weren't meant to be

May 7, 2010 13:47 GMT  ·  By

Google has recently revealed its redesigned homepage and has been rolling it out to users around the world. It’s a massive overhaul and one of the biggest changes in history for Google, certainly in the last decade. As you can imagine, the decision was not made lightly. In fact, work on the new homepage can be traced back to 2006 in one form or another. Google decided to let people in on some of the processes that led to the new design and even shared some of the versions that were rejected.

One of the biggest changes is the new permanent sidebar. It adjusts to the query you are conducting and provides you with additional tools and filters. Most of the options were already available on Google, but hidden by default.

“We’ve been creating mocks of left-hand panels since the earliest days of Google and have tested these designs with users as far back as 2006. Overall, we’ve found they can provide a great way to navigate without getting in the way of the main content, but they can also be distracting. Our users want more powerful tools, but they also want the simplicity they’ve come to expect from Google,” Jon Wiley, senior user experience designer at Google, wrote.

Google took a gradual approach by fist introducing the “Show options“ feature last year. With the new design, Google went all the way and made the sidebar visible by default.

Review image
One of the early Google homepage design experiments
The second big change is in the look of the site, specifically the colors. Interestingly, Google says the brighter colors were designed, in part, to offset some of the added ‘weight‘ of the permanent sidebar. The team started with the Google logo, which lost some of its shading and embossing. The result is a flatter, lighter logo, which would set the tone for the rest of the pages.
Review image
A later design experiment still featuring a blue search button
Still, that doesn’t mean that everything after that came easily. Google went through numerous variants and changes trying to get the design just right and adapting to the user feedback. One of the early design choices was to make the search buttons, on the homepage and on the search results page, blue. Google really wanted the buttons to be blue for some reason and experimented with several versions, but, fortunately in the end, went with the more subtle silver ones after the blue ones were panned by users.
Review image
Review image
One of the first designs with a lot of bright colors
An experiment with "Universal blocks"