Glitch exposed details for 1.9% of users, before Let's Encrypt admins intervened and fixed the problem

Jun 12, 2016 02:00 GMT  ·  By

The Let's Encrypt project announced yesterday that a glitch in the email newsletter system they used accidentally exposed the email addresses of 7,618 users.

Let's Encrypt is a project launched by the Mozilla Foundation and the Electronic Frontier Foundation aimed at providing free SSL certificates, so site owners without large budgets can afford to run their sites via HTTPS.

The project is extremely popular and in mid-April was bragging about having issued over 1.7 million certificates and protected 3.8 million domains.

Some of the Let's Encrypt users also signed up for the project's newsletter, along with non-users, to receive various updates and project news. In total, the project says it has over 383,000 users subscribed to its newsletter.

On June 11, 2016, the Let's Encrypt project started sending emails to all newsletter subscribers about an update to their subscriber agreement.

Glitch in third-party platform is to blame

Like most companies, the project employed a third-party service to handle this task. According to Josh Aas Let's Encrypt ISRG Executive Director, there was a bug in this system, which started prepending the email of all users who were in the newsletter queue.

For example, the tenth person in the queue could see the email addresses of the first nine, the eleventh could see the email addresses for the first ten, and so on.

Users who received these emails quickly spotted the problems and reported the issues (1, 2, 3) to the project's owners, who then intervened and stopped the newsletter queue, but not before sending these malformed newsletters to 7,618 users, which is 1.9% of the entire subscriber base.

"If you received one of these emails we ask that you not post lists of email addresses publicly," Aas pleaded email recipients. Aas also promised a future incident report on what exactly happened.

Let's Encrypt email containing extra email addresses
Let's Encrypt email containing extra email addresses
Let's Encrypt Full Statement

Photo Gallery (2 Images)

Let's Encrypt server glitch exposes user passwords
Let's Encrypt email containing extra email addresses
Open gallery