NEWS CATEGORIES:



NEWS ARCHIVE >>
SOFTPEDIA REVIEWS >>
MEET THE EDITORS >>
Home / News / Science / Behavior/Humans

Behavior/Humans


Biological View: What Do Dying People Feel?

In the end, it's about brain death

By Stefan Anitei, Science Editor

22nd of October 2007, 18:06 GMT

Adjust text size:



Enlarge picture
Have you ever wondered what a dying person feels? It sounds morbid, but science and accounts from lucky survivors have helped us make an idea about it. Still, only the dead know exactly how it feels and the sensations you experience at that moment.

A report released by New Scientist earlier this month answered to some questions related to the feelings and sensations a person experiences in various ways of dying. But what's the medical/biological support for all these aspects? Read on!

Generally, a person is considered dead when blood circulation (translated in heart activity) has stopped. This is the clinical death, but in many cases, modern technology has permitted the restart / recovery of heart activity - such methods include cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), defibrillation, epinephrine shots. So perhaps it would be more biologically correct to say that the person has died when the brain is dead.

Still, the only way to instantly kill the brain is by shooting a bullet into someone's head. There are other ways in which the brain is killed more slowly, mainly by stopping its blood supply. The brain can function for a while without nutrients, but the brain cells (neurons) die in a matter of seconds when they lack oxygen. In fact, this is called a stroke: the death of some brain portions.

In most cases of death, the victim's brain is killed … 'indirectly' (so to say), by stopping the heart (the so-called heart attack). The heart attack can be spontaneous, caused by heart coronary disease (when the heart muscle is deprived of its circulation, and portions of it die). The main symptom is angina pectoris, the famous chest pain, a sensation of pain and squeezing radiating mainly to the left arm but also to all the surrounding areas, accompanied by massive sweating, nausea and palpitations. The asphyxiated brain loses consciousness in a maximum of 10 seconds, and minutes later the brain dies.

Decapitation was believed to be rapid and painless, but it takes about 7 seconds for the brain to lose
consciousness. Eye and facial expressions (grimaces) still persist for 30 seconds after the head has been cut off, which leads us to probably the most famous such case in world history, that of the French queen Marie Antoinette - what could the grimace on the face of this unlucky queen (guillotined during the French revolution) mean? That famous smile was surely not one of happiness.

Lethal injection is considered a 'humane' alternative to the electric chair and attempts to stop the heart while stopping the functions of the brain through three active principles: an anesthetic (like sodium thiopental), a paralytic agent (like pancuronium bromide) and potassium chloride (ultrashort-acting sedative). A mixture of these should be redundant: if one chemical does not kill the inmate, one of the other two will do it. Many people believe that the potassium chloride injection causes burning pain, but the paralyzed convicted cannot show what he/she feels. If the dosage is not the right one, or if the one performing the injection misses the vein, the victim will not only feel a burning sensation caused by the chloride, but it will take him up to 9 minutes to die of asphyxiation due to the blocked breath muscles.

Hanging should be an unconsciousness asphyxiation, occurring in 10 seconds: the convicted should be left unconscious and paralyzed by choking, having the neck broken from the first cervical vertebra, and death should come in a matter of seconds, maximum 2 minutes. The reality is more shocking: over three quarters of the convicted die after a torture of many minutes, during which they desperately try to breathe.

Judicial hangings, opposed to suicides, cause a significant damage to the spinal cord. When the fall is longer than predicted, the victim may even be decapitated. Sometimes, intense fear can induce a cardiac arrest to the convicted. It was quite an offence for royalties to be hanged, as the victim loses control of its sphincters (anal and urethral).

Drowning is in the end also a type of asphyxiation. The panicked victim tries to hold his breath, but they generally live up to 90 seconds without breathing, and even diving champions cannot resist over 6 minutes. The human brain is highly intolerant to the accumulation of carbon dioxide (a result of the cell respiration) in the blood irrigating the brain, and the urge for breathing cannot be stopped. Drowning survivors described a "tearing and burning" sensation when water floods the lungs, followed by a feeling of tranquility, as the brain can no longer sustain high activity. What's next is the same scenario: the lack of oxygen leads to consciousness loss, heart attack, and brain death.

Blood loss, called hemorrhagic shock in medicine, produces in the end the same effect: no oxygen for the cells. That's why victims that are massively bleeding breathe so heavily: the lungs are trying to send more oxygen to the oxygen-hungry body.

A 70 kg (180 pounds) man has about 5.6 liters of blood (8% of the body weight). Losing 1.5 liters of blood makes the individual feel weak, since all the blood has gone from the organs (including muscles) towards the lungs and heart, which try to compensate for the oxygen deficit. The adrenalin released to increase blood pressure in the arteries causes anxiety. Arginine vasopressin released to keep the water in the kidneys (the organism loses a lot of water through blood) makes the individual feel thirsty.

If the blood loss is not stopped, and the body has already lost 2 liters of blood, these compensating mechanisms fail. The ion balance is destroyed, and the blood flow through capillaries is constricted. The cells can no longer function, and fluid and protein leakage out of the cells occurs. At this stage, even if the victim receives blood, the prolonged vasoconstiction has caused irremediable damage. The unoxygenated brain falls into dizziness and confusion, followed by unconsciousness.

If the aortic or pulmonary artery dissection has taken place, pain similar to heart attack can occur.
Electrocution through a household device can paralyze the heart (heart attack), interfering with its own electric signal coordinating the contraction of the heart muscle. Much powerful shocks go beyond electrical impairment of the body, destroying tissues. Damage to the heart tissue means heart attack, but to the brain it causes rapid unconsciousness, if not instant death. Those executed on the electric chair can even experience tissue burning and paralysis of the breath muscles, of course, through asphyxiation.
When falling from a height, the heart does not stop, it breaks into pieces. Usually, the ribs break in many pieces, which stab all the organs around. The thoracic shock, causing instant death, prevails amongst suicide jumpers. Survivors of such incidents describe the feeling of time slowing down.

Burning the heretics was believed to be the worst kind of death during the Medieval Ages. But a sufficiently big fire kills the victims before them being touched by the flames, as the smoke gases, especially carbon monoxide, combine with the hemoglobin - the blood's red pigment carrying oxygen to tissues. The hemoglobin can no longer transport the oxygen to the tissues, and even if the victim is taken out of the burning building, or saved by firemen, he/she will die since the brain cannot be oxygenated.

If the flames touch the skin of the conscious victim, they will induce tremendous pain, which slowly decreases with the destruction of the skin nerves, but persists, as inner tissues have pain sensors too.
Carbon monoxide is also the main culprit for sleep asphyxiation death cases caused by broken stoves (the gas is the result of incomplete burning of wood or any other fuel). This is perhaps the less painful death, also employed by suicidal people using car smoke generated in a closed room.

Explosive decompression means a sudden (less than 0.1 seconds) air pressure drop, caused by violent explosion, like in the case of a contained system (inner airplane) exposed in a moment to outer atmosphere or explosions caused by gas accumulation.

No, people do not …explode… in such cases. The exposure to low pressure causes swelling, but our skin is elastic and resistant and can cope with a drop of one atm. (the required drop for killing a person is of about 8 atmospheres). Survivors of such events reported chest pain, similar to the one you feel when someone hits you hard (due to the swelling of the lungs), and even the feeling of air going out of the lungs. If oxygenation is impeded, the individual loses consciousness in 15 seconds and dies of asphyxiation.

TAGS:

death | kill | brain | heart | blood
Read by 22,877 user(s) | Add comment | Link to this article TWEET THIS


Article rating:
Good (3.4/5) 15 vote(s)    

Subscribe to news | Print article | Send to friend

© Copyright 2001-2009 Softpedia
Contact:

 

 

SEARCH THE NEWS ARCHIVE :




Today's News
| Yesterday's News | News Archive


MORE RELATED ARTICLES:


Scientists Solve the Mysteries of the Frozen Inca Child Mummies

Marrying Your Cousin Increases More Than Twice the Death Risk for Your Children

How Does HIV Evolve, from Birth to Death?

A T-rex Footprint?

Obesity Linked to Cancer

The Deadly Light of Sex

How Is the Brain of the Anorexic Women Different?

Most Man-to-Woman Operated Transsexuals - Pleased with the Results of the Surgery

User opinions:


Comment #1 by: some one on 26 Dec 2007, 13:02 GMT reply to this comment

that was too good.
complete analysis of various factor, we dont get to know other wise...
Thanks a lot


Comment #2 by: Sam on 13 Sep 2008, 00:25 GMT reply to this comment

There are a lot more deaths to die from that were not covered in this entry but I suppose that kind of essay would become more of a book than anything. I guess what we've learned here is that the two most painless suicides are a shot to the head or breathing in carbon monoxide in a closed space? Quite interesting. And I also thought the painful way of burning to death would be one of the most painful deaths, but they say the gases get to you before the flames (sometimes); and that even if you are concious as the flames touch you, you soon lose the feeling in your body as the nerves are being burnt away? (That still seems very, very painful). Another thing that was interesting to me, was when I read about drowning. The "tearing and burning" feeling was something I had never heard before, though I have heard of the feeling of "peacefulness" after the victim breathes in the water. A bit hard to grasp that idea, since I cannot even imagine how to breathe in water. That would be most uncomfortable, to say the least.

Very interesting.


Comment #3 by: Marion on 24 Sep 2009, 02:08 GMT reply to this comment

this was an excellent review. i am expecially interested in finding out if all patients feel pain. a discuccion started at work on different ways of dying and if all of those ways have 'pain'. my mom passed away 'peacefully.' she was holding my dads hand and my hand and just closed her eyes. no expression of pain what so ever. i am not convinced that every person has pain when dying. hospice RN's said there is always pain. can you please make a comment on this. thank you

Share your opinion:

Your Name:
Your Email Address:
(will not be used for commercial purposes)
Solve this to prove you're not a bot: =
Your review/opinion:

 




Windows tabGames tabDrivers tabMac tabLinux tabScripts tabMobile tabHandheld tabGadgets tabNews tab

SUBMIT PROGRAM   |   ADVERTISE   |   GET HELP   |   SEND US FEEDBACK   |   RSS FEEDS   |   ENTER NEWS SITE   |   ENGLISH BOARD   |   ROMANIAN FORUM