Softpedia
 

NEWS CATEGORIES:



NEWS ARCHIVE >>
SOFTPEDIA REVIEWS >>
MEET THE EDITORS >>
Home > News > Life and Style > Stay fit

March 20th, 2009, 11:42 GMT · By

The ‘Kelly Clarkson Is Fat’ Controversy: Enough Is Enough

SHARE:

Adjust text size:


Kelly Clarkson on “American Idol” last week
Enlarge picture
Kelly Clarkson, as all fans must know, has never quite fit the Hollywood standards of female beauty. Of course, that is not to say that she is fat or unhealthy, just that, being a normal-sized girl has often got her negative press specifically on account of her body. The same is happening now, the only difference being that, this time, women all over the world are speaking against the image bullying the media and the Internet are encouraging.

Kelly recently appeared on two major television shows to perform. And no one (or only too few people) focused on how she sang or on whether she was still as able to carry a tune as she was when she won the first edition of “American Idol” and shot to international fame. Instead, bloggers and journalists ran stories on Kelly’s obvious (or so they said) weight-gain, placing bets on the possibility that she might even be pregnant.

Enough is enough, women all over the world are saying, with Margarita Bertsos of Glamour magazine in the first row. In a society that is obsessed with body image, it’s not a surprise that we still focus on it instead of on what really matters.

As Bertsos says, Kelly took the stage to sing and not to model the latest creation from Karl Lagerfeld, so why are we so fixated on her weight? Whether the star gains some pounds or not is a matter of choice, and the public only has the right to criticize her if she fails us as a singer – which she hasn’t done so far.

“I keep reading headlines in the papers and from fans online speculating – ridiculously – on whether Kelly is pregnant. Why? Because of her curves. Um, am I the only one who thinks her ‘baby bump’ looks more like a big lunch than a set of twins? Her reps have squashed the rumors, of course. But when I read comments on the Web like this one: ‘She’s gotten huge! I just saw her on SNL. Lay off the Twinkies, or you’re going to have a lot of new material about guys breaking up with you,’ I can’t help but sympathize. My two cents on the subject: She’s not on America’s Next Top Model. Her body = her business. Our business? Her music! And I’m no doctor, but I think Kelly’s curves hardly qualify for the nation’s obesity intervention.” Bertsos writes for the aforementioned publication.

Sadly, Kelly’s case is not an isolated one. Just recently, Meghan McCain has also admitted to often being a victim of image-oriented bullying, lashing out against the media for placing too much emphasis on weight than on real values or a woman’s achievements. On the bright side, both Kelly and Meghan have learned to not pay attention to this kind of criticism, having enough self-confidence to know that what matters is only how they feel inside.

TELL US WHAT YOU THINK:

4,855 hits · 8 comments · Link to this article · Print article · Send to friend · Subscribe to news

MUST-READ RELATED ARTICLES:


Meghan McCain Lashes Out Against Image-Oriented Bullying

Kelly Clarkson Knows She Is a Horrible Actress

Kelly Clarkson Breaks Billboard Record with New Single

Fit at Home with Trainer Marco Borges and Heidi Klum

The Secret to Alessandra Ambrosio’s Amazing Post-Baby Body

READER COMMENTS:


Comment #1 by: Matt on 21 Mar 2009, 12:23 UTC reply to this comment

Kelly Clarkson is a beautiful singer and beautiful person. It's sad that people resort to issues of no relevance that is most likely done due to jealousy of her overwhelming success. They can't fault her voice, personality, popularity and style so they resort to other means to gain attention for themselves. The individuals who engage in such behavior really need to take a hard look at themselves.


Comment #2 by: Steve on 24 Mar 2009, 01:28 UTC reply to this comment

I think Kelly is hotter than ever! I dont understand why people talk so much crap about weight. There so many guys out there that wont admit they like a curvy girl like her. I DO!!! But now she will probably go out and lose all the weight just to satisfy all the negative a-holes who post horrible things. I think she is awesome!!!!


Comment #3 by: lucy on 22 May 2009, 14:16 UTC reply to this comment

I think she's beautiful fat or not. When she's fat, she's so much more beautiful :) .

I love her, i love her voice, i love her body, and i think everyone should leave her alone..

The body is important for the voice? NO.
so, america, leave kelly clarkson and her body, please


Comment #4 by: betsy on 06 Jun 2009, 02:06 UTC reply to this comment

why can't people leave others alone with the way they look. why can't they just accept them for who they are. i think kelly clarkson is beautiful. she has an amazing voice. leave it is what is inside that counts and i believe she has a beautiful soul as well.


Comment #5 by: Oscar Blyth on 06 Jun 2009, 14:40 UTC reply to this comment

Yes, but because she looks this way, it means we can _only_ appreciate her sound. It reduces the quality of her live performance because there's no appealing visual element. Of course her sound is mostly what sells her, but how many guys buy music because they like to fantasize about the attractive girl that's singing to them! NKOTB are far more popular than Meatloaf!

I'm sure you see my point.


Comment #6 by: Sara on 01 Jul 2009, 22:22 UTC reply to this comment

Kelly Clarkson is not FAT! Now John Goodman is Fat! I think Kelly looks health and happy, and people should leave her alone and let her live her life the way she wants. You are just mad becasue she has more fame and fortune then you all could ever think about having. Oh did i mention a voice to die for...


Comment #7 by: KAT on 20 Aug 2009, 15:30 UTC reply to this comment

Yes, she is a talented musician, but she is overweight. It is NOT healthy to be that size, therefore, for her own well-being, she should lose some weight.
Furthermore, lots of her fans see her as a rolemodel. Some of these fans are impressionable teenagers. She needs to set an example for them by appearing healthy (otherwise it's as if she's proving being that fat is fine). 2/3 of Americans are obese. Obesity entails lots of serious health problems. Snap out of it guys, and hit the gym instead of the internet. Get some fresh air and learn to cook, so you survive on healthy food rather than junk. Or you're going to have very short life spans. It's the sad truth, being fat is no good for you.


Comment #8 by: drak on 26 Aug 2010, 04:01 UTC reply to this comment

Are you freaking kidding me? kelly fat? people are retarded,not everyone lives on peas.She's gorgeous like she is,GOD

Copyright © 2001-2012 Softpedia. Contact/Tip us at

WindowsGamesDriversMacLinuxScriptsMobileHandheldNews

SUBMIT PROGRAM   |   ADVERTISE   |   GET HELP   |   SEND US FEEDBACK   |   RSS FEEDS   |   UPDATE YOUR SOFTWARE   |   ROMANIAN FORUM