Despite not being officially “out of the closet,” it seems that Lindsay Lohan and Samantha Ronson’s relationship is already doomed, if we’re to believe what several eyewitness and countless tabloids and gossip blogs are telling us. One night in particular is mostly mentioned, what is also called the most important night of the year, New Year’s Eve, which is when Lindsay reportedly raised hell with Sam.

The duo was in Miami co-hosting a party at the posh club Mansion, which is where trouble first began. According to witnesses, and as can be seen in several videos posted on the Internet, it was Lindsay who first lashed out at Samantha, with whom she has reportedly been involved for a few months now. Whatever it was that they were fighting over could still not be determined.

Reports have it that, once the two ringed in the new year, they took their fight outside and away from the prying eyes of the other partygoers who had already seen enough. “It was a really gross alley. There was a bum eating a sandwich watching the whole thing. Lindsay was really unstable and flipping out.” one eyewitness told the tabs about how the fighting continued in a back alley.

And this was not all, several media outlets are saying. After they had done their hosting duties, the two quarrelling lovers took their feud to the hotel room, which they trashed and smashed until the neighbors were forced to call the police. While security was taking shots of the now-upside down room, Lindsay and Samantha reportedly continued to fight on the hallways, in plain view of the other guests and obviously not caring about who saw them.

“They were punching each other - it was bad. And they were doing this in front of all of us. It was scary.” another spy told the media. To add more fuel to the fire/drama, at one point, Lindsay “dropped to her knees and shouted ‘Why are you doing this to me?’ [and] SamRo responded, ‘I don't know you’.” 

When contacted for comment on these incidents, one of Lindsay’s mouthpieces would say only that “There was an argument - I don't know the details - but they left for LA together and it’s fine.”