Softpedia
 

NEWS CATEGORIES:



NEWS ARCHIVE >>
SOFTPEDIA REVIEWS >>
MEET THE EDITORS >>
Home > News > Science > Nano-Biotechnology

March 29th, 2008, 08:57 GMT · By Gabriel Gache

LHC to Destroy the Earth... Not

SHARE:

Adjust text size:


Artistic impression of a black hole accreting matter from a star in its vicinity
Enlarge picture
The Large Hadron Collider is quickly approaching completion and is expected to begin operation by the middle of the this year. However, while physicists are barely waiting to start experimenting with the world's most powerful particle accelerator, campaigners in the United States would give anything to see the LHC delayed as long as possible or to stop it from ever operating altogether. They believe that, during experiments, dangerous particles or possibly mini black holes will be created and they could destroy the whole Earth in the process.

For example, almost a week ago a couple of residents from Hawaii, namely Luis Sancho and Walter Wagner, initiated a lawsuit against the European Organization for Nuclear Research,
owner of the LHC particle accelerator, demanding that the LHC should be stopped from becoming operational before it is proved to be safe. The funny thing it that the US also contributed to the build through the Department of Energy, the National Science Foundation and Fermilab.

According to CERN spokesman James Gillies, the lawsuit initiated by the two men has no scientific foundation, it is a complete nonsense. "The LHC will star up this year, and it will produce all sorts of exciting new physics and knowledge about the universe. A year from now, the world will still be here," said Gillies.

During experiments, the LHC will smash hadron particles - elementary particles made out of quarks - at extremely high energies, in order to recreate the exact conditions that existed less than a billionth of a second after the big bang. By doing so, they hope to be able to understand why particles carry mass or whether the universe has extra hidden dimensions or not.

Particles of death

Wagner and Sancho believe that the LHC will create particles, 'killer strangelets', which will swallow the whole Earth if they escape the particle accelerator. According to theory, strangelet particles are hypothetical structures formed of strange quarks and several other flavors of quarks that make up hadrons - such as protons and neutrons.

It is widely believed that strangelet particles are unstable and should disintegrate as soon as they are created. However, campaigners against the LHC say that stable and negatively charged strangelets may be created ,if escaped out of the particles accelerator, they may begin disintegrating the nuclei of ordinary matter, a chain reaction that could in theory destroy the whole universe.

Nonetheless, LHC engineers revealed more than five years ago in a safety review report that there is "no basis for any conceivable threat". There is an extremely small chance that magnetic monopoles or mini black holes could be created inside such a collider and even if they occur, they would be too short lived to cause any damage.

Previously, Wagner initiated a similar lawsuit against the operation of the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider, located at Brookhaven National Laboratory. "RHIC started running in 2000 and we're still here," added Gillies.

No danger

In fact, collisions like those taking place inside the LHC occur every second throughout the universe, as cosmic ray particles collide with each other at relativistic speed. The Earth and the Moon have been experiencing collisions with such particles ever since they were created 5 billion years ago, so we shouldn't be here if Wagner was right.

"There is no question that should the defendants inadvertently create a dangerous form of matter such as a micro black hole or a strangelet, or otherwise create unsafe conditions of physics, then the environmental impact would be both local and national in scope, and quite deadly to everyone," claim the accusers in their lawsuit case.

"What we want to do is get this machine up and running. We'll show people that the world is not going to disappear," said Gillies. Unconfirmed sources say that a judge was already assigned to the case and the first hearing will take place on 16 June.

TELL US WHAT YOU THINK:

3,772 hits · 4 comments · Link to this article · Print article · Send to friend · Subscribe to news

MUST-READ RELATED ARTICLES:


Bs Mesons, the Key to Antimatter Mystery

LHC Build Completed. Still Much Work to be Done Though

Standard Model Confirmed by Computer Simulations

Dark Matter and Dark Energy One and the Same?

LHC Starts the Search for Sparticles in April

READER COMMENTS:


Comment #1 by: JTankers on 04 Apr 2008, 00:15 UTC reply to this comment

CERNs web site states that we have not been destroyed by effects of cosmic rays and micro black holes will evaporate.

However, cosmic rays travel too fast to be captured by Earths gravity, and Hawking Radiation is disputed and contradicts Einsteins highly successful relativity theory. Collider particles smash head on like a car collision and can be captured by Earths gravity, and relativity predicts micro black holes will not decay (Hawking called Einstein doubly wrong, yet it is Einstein who is repeatedly found to have been correct in his theories). There is currently no reasonable proof of LHC safety, LSAG (LHC Safety Assessment Group) has been trying for months to prove safety without success. I hold the minority opinion that it may not be possible because it may in fact not be safe.

Cosmic Rays from the legal complaint.

any such novel particle created in nature by cosmic ray impacts would be left with a velocity at nearly the speed of light, relative to earth. At such speeds, . . . , is believed by most theorists to simply pass harmlessly through our planet with nary an impact, safely exiting on the other side. . . . Conversely, any such novel particle that might be created at the LHC would be at slow speed relative to earth, a goodly percentage would then be captured by earths gravity, and could possibly grow larger [accrete matter] with disastrous consequences of the earth turning into a large black hole.

If this thing is so safe, why arent CERN scientists allowed to express any personal fears they might have about this Collider?

Alleged in the legal action: Chief Scientific Officer, Mr. Engelen passed an internal memorandum to workers at CERN, asking them, regardless of personal opinion, to affirm in all interviews that there were no risks involved in the experiments, changing the previous assertion of minimal risk.

(Statisticians generally consider minimal risk as 1-10%).

JTankers
LHCConcerns.com


Comment #2 by: Hamish on 10 Sep 2008, 08:31 UTC reply to this comment

Oh no this is terrible ..


Comment #3 by: nick on 10 Sep 2008, 15:00 UTC reply to this comment

Being a normal bloke living in france, I am surprised that I never heard about this until I was looking at the home page of yahoo.

I find it a bit worrying that science uses so much mony to do an experiment of this kind when there are so many other things to spend it on which will help humanity, more so than finding mini black holes and particles that may exist in another dimentions.

Another question, why is this test being done on such a tiny vulnerable fragile planet that still has monkeys running around killing each other with clubs??

shouldn't we be concentrating on the problems here rather than delving into the depths of the uknown???

One more thought: If the universe is infinite and we are not the only forms of "intelegent" life, then surely one of the other species would have done something similaire.

What makes us so special, I find it hard to believe that we are as clever as all that. We can't even stop the govornement from using petrol when there are perfectly good substitutes, what chance do we have in stopping a bunch of einstein wannabe's from playing with their toys???

Only time will tell the fate of mankind.


Comment #4 by: kayleighlouise on 22 May 2009, 01:46 UTC reply to this comment

"and all should leave geneva!"
REMEMBER NOSTRADAMUS!!!!
LOOK IT UP.
HE HAS ALMOST 100% RECORD OF PREDICTIONS.
STOP THIS MACHEINE!
I DONT WANT TO DIE!

Copyright © 2001-2012 Softpedia. Contact/Tip us at

WindowsGamesDriversMacLinuxScriptsMobileHandheldNews

SUBMIT PROGRAM   |   ADVERTISE   |   GET HELP   |   SEND US FEEDBACK   |   RSS FEEDS   |   UPDATE YOUR SOFTWARE   |   ROMANIAN FORUM