Softpedia
 

NEWS CATEGORIES:



NEWS ARCHIVE >>
SOFTPEDIA REVIEWS >>
MEET THE EDITORS >>
Home > News > Microsoft > Internet Explorer

March 3rd, 2008, 18:10 GMT · By

Is Internet Explorer Safer Than Firefox, Opera and Safari?

SHARE:

Adjust text size:



Enlarge picture
The face-off for dominance on the browser market is essentially a four-horse race between Internet Explorer, Firefox, Safari and Opera. Now, the truth of the matter is that Internet Explorer has long become the preferred browser worldwide, starting with the moment it was bundled with Windows and offered for free in order to beat Netscape at its own game. Firefox comes in second in terms of install base, enjoying the backing of Google, with Safari in third place thanks to the Mac OS X and with Opera a distant fourth. But along with market share, security is another relevant aspect of the browser war.

Now, Microsoft has been claiming throughout 2007 that Internet Explorer
has the smallest volume of vulnerabilities compared to all rival products. The statistics put together by Jeff Jones, a Security Strategy Director in Microsoft's Trustworthy Computing group, illustrating IE's superiority in terms of the sheer number of vulnerabilities do not offer a true perspective over the actual level of security provided by each browser. But at the same time, the data turned out to be correct, as supported by a recent report from Cenzic.

"Application vulnerabilities in Q4 tracked the first three quarters in terms of their dominance, forming 71 percent, a three percent increase over Q3, of the total 1,404 published vulnerabilities. The scary part is that 70 percent of these vulnerabilities are easily exploitable. Application vulnerabilities are the ones that pertain to Web technologies including Web servers, Web browsers, and Web applications. (...) In the browser category, surprisingly Internet Explorer had less vulnerability than Safari, Opera, and Mozilla Firefox browsers," Mandeep Khera, VP of Marketing, Cenzic.

Web Browser Vulnerabilities
Enlarge picture
Cenzic revealed that only 10% of all browser security flaws in 2007 impacted Internet Explorer. The next in line is Safari with 15% and then Firefox with no less than 32% of vulnerabilities. Judging strictly by the number of vulnerabilities, Opera is the most insecure browser, having been impacted by no less than 38% of vulnerabilities.

"Vulnerabilities in Web browsers were concentrated among four popular technologies - Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Opera, and Safari. Showing a similar trend as Q3 2007, the Opera Web browser with 38 percent had the most reported vulnerabilities during the Q4 time period, with Firefox coming in second by a 6 percent margin. The chart below shows the percentage of the total browser vulnerabilities associated with each product. Unlike previous quarters, less vulnerabilities were reported in Internet Explorer than in Opera, Firefox, or Safari," reads an excerpt from the Cenzic report.
FILED UNDER:
IE
Firefox
Opera
Safari

TELL US WHAT YOU THINK:

26,547 hits · 8 comments · Link to this article · Print article · Send to friend · Subscribe to news

MUST-READ RELATED ARTICLES:


Mozilla Says Firefox 3.0 Beta 4 Is Cooking as IE8 Beta 1 Starts Shipping

Browser Beta Fiesta, Not Only IE8 Beta 1 But Also Firefox 3.0 Beta 4

Forget IE8 and Firefox 3.0 Beta 3 - the New Internet Explorer 7 Is Here!

Microsoft and Mozilla Plug Critical Holes in Internet Explorer 7 and Firefox 2.0

Firefox 3.0 Beta 3 Available for Download

READER COMMENTS:


Comment #1 by: Dan Silbert on 05 Mar 2008, 18:56 UTC reply to this comment

Of course number of vulnerabilities is one way to look at it. Patching those vulnerabilities is another thing entirely.

According to Secunia.com, all Opera vulnerabilities have been patched, while both Mozilla and Microsoft have not patched all the vulnerabilities in their products.

Now that I think about it, there are many more useful security indicators than just number of vulnerabilities. This Cenzic report is only moderately useful at best.


Comment #2 by: Phil on 07 Mar 2008, 05:31 UTC reply to this comment

I have personal experienced far fewer problems since switching to Opera than I had when i used IE. I must admit, though, that Opera is a little faster, takes less room on my desktop, has more intuitive interface options, and has a much nicer tab system than IE. Of course, I think in the end it comes down to personal preference. After all, regardless of how many vulnerabilities you fix, there will always be new ones. That's the problem with security. Nothing is completely safe. Keep your scanners updated and running.


Comment #3 by: IE8 safer than Firefox on 27 Jan 2010, 10:45 UTC reply to this comment

Dan Silbert is either retarded or stoned, LOL. You see the problem is that EVERY ONE, assumes that Microsoft will be the worst at security. Why? Because they've hit some bumps in the past.

But what about today? I don't think it's true any more. And it seems the writer of this article is hinting at that very truth. I'm not saying IE8 is malware proof. No. But I think it's safer. I conducted my own test over the course of months between Firefox and IE8. My system has been attacked by drop by virus attacks about 3 times while running FireFox. I run NO virus scanner so I can see what happens. I also can do this because I keep full system backups and can restore in minutes. But so far I can't recall a single time where running IE8 has resulted in a virus or malware attack off a random web site.

I'm talking about the kind where you are sitting there and suddenly you know you are infected because your computer is scanning with a fake scanner saying so. That's what happened under firefox. Boom and I was infected. This happened under XP. Under Windows 7, nothing so far...

People are NEVER, EVER, EVER going to admit that IE8 might be more secure. But after nearly a year of this and getting attacked under Firefox, yet never IE8, I'm starting to believe IE8 really is safer.


Comment #4 by: IE8 safer than Safari on 27 Jan 2010, 10:52 UTC reply to this comment

Also one more interesting point. Note that Safari is a browser made by Apple and should be pretty secure since their programmers are of course sent from Lord Jobs. But unfortunately Safari, coded by Apple, is full of vulnerabilities. Thus showing what might happen if osx were main stream. The only reason macs don't get infected as often is because the code that's trying to be injected through a security hole won't run on a mac because it was written for windows. I've often heard of mac users saying some strange "thing" was scanning their hard drives. And someone will always say, "don't worry it won't run, it's for windows". Which is true, but proves that apple isn't any better at this.


Comment #5 by: Shin Aska109 on 15 Apr 2010, 10:52 UTC reply to this comment

I've used almost all of the browsers available of the net, and I must say... Internet Explorer 8 is already reliable for me (not saying that it has the best browser security), While web surfing the other week, IE8 already caught alot of website that is identified as an attack site/suspicious site. however as a downside, for my computer it starts and loads site very slow and those reasons lead me to change to another browser (not firefox because for me its a 5 star browser in terms of hogging your computer's memory up.) but browser such as Google Chrome and Opera, I heard rumors about IE7pro has the functions to make IE8 much more faster, but haven't tried this yet.


Comment #6 by: Paul on 06 May 2010, 20:27 UTC reply to this comment

This is not true for me..
I got viruses from IE when i didnt to Opera
Although Opera is not secure, many people do not use it
Therefore, not a lot of viruses are created towards Opera
So I believe this results are useless


Comment #7 by: Gary on 17 Jun 2010, 05:49 UTC reply to this comment

The problem I see with Internet Explorer is that it can run ActiveX objects. FireFox doesn't do so, by design. ActiveX objects are a security risk because they can do virtually anything on your machine that your user account can do. And if you are using a Home version of the OS you probably have administrator rights. The objects can be, and often are, downloaded from the website. An example of using ActiveX objects is Microsoft's Microsoft Update which writes to the user's disk to install updates.

Comment #7.1 by: ma on 29 Aug 2011, 21:40 GMT

I agree, I just got attack by a virus when running ie8 and Activex can be dangerous. In Firefox, you don't have this issue.

Copyright © 2001-2012 Softpedia. Contact/Tip us at

WindowsGamesDriversMacLinuxScriptsMobileHandheldNews

SUBMIT PROGRAM   |   ADVERTISE   |   GET HELP   |   SEND US FEEDBACK   |   RSS FEEDS   |   UPDATE YOUR SOFTWARE   |   ROMANIAN FORUM