Softpedia
 

NEWS CATEGORIES:



NEWS ARCHIVE >>
SOFTPEDIA REVIEWS >>
MEET THE EDITORS >>
TRENDING TODAY
Home > News > Linux > First-Look

March 3rd, 2009, 08:52 GMT · By

First Look: moonOS 2

SHARE:

Adjust text size:

moonOS 2
Enlarge picture
Though my past experiences with Enlightenment weren't very fruitful, seeing the recent Elive Compiz made me want to see more of this unique window manager.
So I started looking through the available options and I stumbled upon moonOS, which was recently upgraded to version 2, codename Kachana. Having an Ubuntu base and judging by the screenshots I decided to give it a spin and see if it's any worth. The test machine I loaded moonOS onto has the following specs:

· AMD K8 nForce 250Gb Motherboard
· AMD Sempron 2800+ Processor
· Nvdia GeForce FX5200 Video Card
· 512 MB RAM
· LG CD-RW/DVD-ROM Drive
· 17" BENQ T720 Monitor


You know the routine: download the ISO, burn it to a CD, reboot your computer and boot from the CD. Simple. The first possible letdown that you'll come across must be the loading bar, which displays some washed-out dark-green shades. Some will probably like it, I didn't. Moving on to the more important elements of an operating system, the boot process was pretty quick even from the Live CD. After installing it onto your hard drive you should expect startup speed values similar to Ubuntu's. Nothing really worth lingering upon.

The bootsplash image and font prepare you for what I like to call a fairytale desktop. With floral motifs and forest-green shiny colors everywhere (including the cursor) I was certain that a dancing Irish Leprechaun will start hopping around across my workspaces. It didn't, sadly... Oh well, maybe some good folks will create an animated wallpaper displaying just that. And, as some of you may already know, Enlightenment supports animated wallpapers: a fading ladybird, lights turning on and off in a city landscape or a pong game for the nostalgics. But don't think that you will have to dig the web to find them, as the appearance settings will have an "online" button that will take you to the wallpaper portal so you can look through either static or animated ones. There aren't a lot, but you'll certainly find one that will suit your mood. Ecomorph, a Compiz implementation for E17, is also included but not enabled by default given the fact that a warning on the website says: "[...] this is currently somewhere between a hack and planning/pre-alpha state."

moonOS 2 Gadgets
Enlarge picture
moonOS 2 Assistant
Enlarge picture
moonOS 2
Enlarge picture
moonOS 2
Enlarge picture
moonOS 2
Enlarge picture


The desktop hosts quite a big dock that is placed on the right side of the screen and displays some of the most popular applications that you'll surely need to use eventually: Firefox, GIMP, Thunderbird, OpenOffice.org (which, by the way, has an awesome splash screen), Pidgin, Exaile Media Player, Synaptic, Terminal and Thunar. In the bottom-right corner, you'll find a calendar, battery indicator and the trash. Of course, adding new icons to the dock is an easy task. On the upper left side, three huge icons (Home, root, desktop) will sit on top of a hard drive load indicator. The bottom center of the screen is occupied by the usual Enlightenment panel with the menu, workspace and application switcher, CPU temperature, time/date and the volume control knob. Having two "docks" on your screen will eat up quite a lot of screen estate so I wouldn't recommend anything lower than 1280x1024 for your resolution.

Going back to the looks of this distribution, I was very disappointed with the title bar. The color is *ewww* and the buttons are ugly, contrasting with the general beauty moonOS has to offer. Besides the title bar, all shades of green are gorgeous and contribute to that fairytale desktop feel I was telling you about.

Another downside is the fact that the desktop is not actually linked to the desktop folder, so basically you cannot create folders, files etc. like you normally do on a "regular" desktop. But don't think that it's moonOS' fault, as this is how Enlightenment is built. Well, on the bright side, you are sure to always have an uncluttered screen.

moonOS 2 Dock
Enlarge picture
moonOS 2 Pong
Enlarge picture
moonOS 2 Cleanup
Enlarge picture
moonOS 2 Desktop Folder
Enlarge picture
moonOS 2 Browser
Enlarge picture


If you don't fancy Enlightenment as your desktop environment and want something more "traditional," moonOS 2 is also available in an LXDE edition. Both versions of moonOS 2 are a joy to look at and use. I didn't find any major problems and the system is not a resource-eating monster so in the end whether you'll use it or not is just a matter of taste.

Download moonOS 2 Main Edition right now from Softpedia.

Download moonOS 2 LXDE Edition right now from Softpedia.


18,536 hits · 9 comments
Link to this article · Print article · Send to friend

MUST-READ RELATED ARTICLES:


Slack Mini Server 1.4.2 Features the DansGuardian Filter

Softpedia Linux Weekly, Issue 35

SystemRescueCd 1.1.6 Is Here

Dreamlinux 3.5 Launched

GNOME Do: The King of Launchers

READER COMMENTS:


Comment #1 by: Russell on 04 Mar 2009, 12:44 UTC reply to this comment

This is the worst review ever. I have no problems with MoonOS with a quad core Intel system, 4GB Ram, Auzentech Sound card etc etc I even have an external wireless usb key that it picked up as well. Everything worked out of tnhe box with nothing needed to install for mp3 playing, movies, flash. This is the only distro that I have had this luck. Also the theme and colours I think are excellent and are visually pleasant and relaxing. One of the best distros I have ever used. Will be putting it onto my eeePC when I get a chance.

Comment #1.1 by: Daniel Pop-Silaghi on 04 Mar 2009, 13:42 GMT

Hello and thank you for your feedback, though I wish you'd be more specific in pointing out what bothered you about this First Look (not a review, by the way). If you read carefully you'll realize that, all in all, I enjoyed moonOS and besides the title bar color, I found nothing wrong with the theme. "Besides the title bar, all shades of green are gorgeous and contribute to that fairytale desktop feel I was telling you about."
Regarding the overall performance of it I was again very pleased to see how it behaved on the low-end machine that we tested it on. "I didn't find any major problems and the system is not a resource-eating monster ..."
So, again, please provide, if possible, a more detailed feedback about the quality of this article.


Comment #2 by: Airdrik on 04 Mar 2009, 16:03 UTC reply to this comment

You can get the desktop icons to appear on the desktop. It's in the enlightenment settings under the Files or File Manager category (Not sure off the top of my head, I'm not at home running it at the moment).
There's even an option to show hal icons (hard disks/partitions, and removable disks/devices) on the desktop (which in this case is redundant since they are showing the places module as a gadget in the top-left corner).

In my experience with using E17, currently my only complaints with Enlightenment is occasional stability (I'm using latest/recent svn builds - sometimes it just freezes and I have to kill x and emphasize updates for a couple days before it goes back to relative stability) and the relative lack of stuff available (there have been few new themes and modules developed over the last year).
Hopefully we will see this remedied soon after the enlightenment devs finally finish (finalize the current loose ends and declare stable) e17 this year.


Comment #3 by: Agust on 07 Mar 2009, 18:38 UTC reply to this comment

Well , first to thank Daniel for his article,although not all agree with what he says.
MoonOS , so far is the only distro that E17 + Ecomorph fully operational.
In five minutes set the effects of Ecomorph and have a fantastic distro.
Recognize the excellent work done on this distro would be reasonable,no?
If you want to use Enlightenemnt with or without Ecomorph the option today is MoonOS.
Greetings:
Agust


Comment #4 by: GiBz on 11 Mar 2009, 15:03 UTC reply to this comment

Well Thanks to your review made me give moonos a try... I was on a distro search for a distribution that me... Well i tried all major in distro watch(mandriva being my favorite) still was really disappointed even thought about going to windows(the agony) well as a last step i installed moon os just to see what e17 looks like... At first i was not that happy... I must agree the default theme is too hard on your eye.... But now working on moonos for 2 days.... I just cant think about any other i would go back... People who maid this distro is raelly talented... I would recommended anyone to give it a try.. really awesome in boot looks and speed... I really pray i would stuble upon some annoying problem as i dis other distro which made me switch...
ps :- I am totally impressed about this distro because of e17...


Comment #5 by: skooal on 18 Mar 2009, 10:21 UTC reply to this comment

Well, I have to say that I am at my 50 something distro, and none really worked for me so far. I decided to stick to distros using the E17 wm in the end.
I tried Elive... very good but impossible to get a sudo line working or a deb package installed properly... (please note that I was using the unstable release, this could be an explanation) otherwise, great job.
Then came
ozOS... couldn't get my wireless card to be recognised... too bad.

OpenGEU came next... on my machine this was unstable to the point that I couldn't work for more than 5 mn without a problem.

So last but not least I gave a try to moonOS... stable, everything is recognised, I am not fan of the theme but this was easy to change... 1 mn all together. I was able to install flock and rawtherapee without a problem...

Best linux distribution for my needs so far.

The downside is that after reding your review I decided to try it last when it should have been the contrary.

Thanks anyway.


Comment #6 by: vaithy on 01 May 2009, 07:18 UTC reply to this comment

some time mazing looks may not be the indication of functionality of any distro.. moon os is a exception..I installed this amazing ubuntu clone on enlightment and never lokked back.. In my desktop with ATI R3450 it is a freeze but in my Compaq presario Laptop it simply freezed in to white screen while booting the CD(as all the ubuntu variants including mint does the same White screen Death a.k.a BSD of 'windoze'.. so it is not the Moon OS fault..But before booting just type the kernal option 'xforcevesa acpi=off noapic' this does the trick..after installation add this same line in the menu.lst against kernal option.. perhaps this is a peculiar to Compaq which has a crippled Bios ?..
About Moon OS it deserve much credit than the other predaters..


Comment #7 by: jmarran on 26 May 2009, 18:55 UTC reply to this comment

I have been an Ubuntu user on and off since 4.10. I am constantly impressed by the ease of use, and the power that Ubuntu brings back to older machines. However, I recently REACQUIRED my faithful 333 MHz PC that I lovingly refer to as "the Guinea Pig". Ubuntu even with XFCE was a bit too much for it...due to the lower speed processor. When I found Moon OS with LXDE, I installed it...and have been quite pleased with the performance, the eye-candy, and the fact that it's STILL Ubuntu.

Great Job!

JM


Comment #8 by: br0keN on 09 Mar 2010, 06:27 UTC reply to this comment

I am downloading this right now. Only thing I know for sure is that it is not easy to setup lxde... but lxde is incredibly fast and sharp looking. This should rock on older hardware. :D

Copyright © 2001-2013 Softpedia. Contact/Tip us at

WindowsGamesDriversMacLinuxScriptsMobileHandheldNews

SUBMIT PROGRAM   |   ADVERTISE   |   GET HELP   |   SEND US FEEDBACK   |   RSS FEEDS   |   UPDATE YOUR SOFTWARE   |   ROMANIAN FORUM