Softpedia
 

NEWS CATEGORIES:



NEWS ARCHIVE >>
SOFTPEDIA REVIEWS >>
MEET THE EDITORS >>
Home > News > Apple > Personal Thoughts

October 27th, 2009, 11:51 GMT · By

Apple Nerve

SHARE:

Adjust text size:


A screenshot from one of Apple's latest TV spots - “PC News”
Enlarge picture
Sure enough, Apple makes a good point in its latest Get a Mac ads targeting PC users’ upgrade to Windows 7. However, we have overlooked one tiny aspect about Apple’s own upgrade to Snow Leopard, and the company seems to act like nothing ever happened. You guessed it - it’s the data-eating bug affecting users who unknowingly upgraded to "the most advanced" OS out there only to find their user accounts wiped clean.

After watching Apple’s latest Get a Mac ads, which capitalize on some of the fuss surrounding the Windows 7 upgrade process, we figured Apple was going to have another good Get-a-Mac year. Adding those angry comments over at Microsoft’s forum, I had just about every reason to laud Apple for the way it handled its customers and, implicitly, its business.

However, while the ads don’t lie, Apple had quite a nerve posting them before addressing one of the most serious bugs ever to plague Mac OS X. Ironically, the bug affects those who upgraded to Snow Leopard. Here’s what happened, just in case you haven’t been reading the tech news lately.

Following the public launch of Mac OS X version 10.6 aka Snow Leopard, Apple Discussions (support forum) users started complaining of a Snow Leopard bug eating away their data. The wipeout happens when the user logs into the 'guest' account, then logs back out of the account, and back into their normal one. Many reported that, not only had their settings been reset, but, in most cases, all data had been erased. The home directory would still appear under "/Users/username," but those affected reported that it was completely empty.

Users claimed their data had become unrecoverable in some cases, and could not be found / accessed anywhere on the hard drive. Only a few lucky cases were reported, where the user had backed up their data. While Apple’s OS X 10.6.2 software update is expected to drop soon with the fix, it is still not clear exactly how many users have been affected to date. However, all signs point to the bug existing on machines that upgraded from OS X 10.5 Leopard with the guest account enabled.

So, how does Apple find the courage to post those ads that bash Windows 7? Easy! The Mac maker is strictly referring to the differences between upgrade policies and, of course, its most satisfying customer care services.

Review image
Apple's new 'Teeter Tottering' ad portrays a female PC user who finds that it's easier to switch to a Mac, rather than upgrade to Microsoft's new Windows 7
Credits: Apple

Apple even made upgrading from Tiger (OS X 10.4) to Snow Leopard (OS X 10.6) a seamless process. The company was also shooting the new TV spots as the aforementioned Snow Leopard bug emerged and, with Windows 7 launched to the public, the ads couldn’t wait any longer.

Hadn’t the Snow Leopard upgrade bug existed, Apple could only be praised for its straightforward thinking and user-friendliness. However, since that’s not the case, the Mac maker’s ongoing Get a Mac campaign doesn’t resonate with us so much anymore.

TELL US WHAT YOU THINK:

2,604 hits · 5 comments · Link to this article · Print article · Send to friend · Subscribe to news

MUST-READ RELATED ARTICLES:


Apple Needs to Sell the Tablet to PC Fans

Download New VMware Fusion 3.0 for Mac OS X

iTablet Speculation Reaches New Heights

Apple Shows How to Replace the Memory on New iMacs

New MacBook Pros Referenced in OS X 10.6.2 Developer Build

READER COMMENTS:


Comment #1 by: Jon T on 27 Oct 2009, 13:18 UTC reply to this comment

Don't forget that the Apple OS makes making up your user files a breeze. So much so that there is simply no longer any excuse not to do it.

Apart from the fact that the Guest account problem took weeks to discover because it affects practically no-one, the upgrade processes between the two systems are simply not comparable.

Apple is, and was, quite right to advertise as they have.


Comment #2 by: Patrick on 27 Oct 2009, 15:34 UTC reply to this comment

Ummmm ya. And how many macs did this affect. Less than 1%. Hmmmm... let's think about that. How many windows 7 users are having trouble? 50%? Ya Microsoft sucks. Just get over it.


Comment #3 by: W. G. on 27 Oct 2009, 15:53 UTC reply to this comment

Hmm, so your suggesting actually backing up your data before upgrading your OS was a valid suggestion? Is this any different on Windows, Solaris, Linux, AIX? Someone show me an OS that says upgrade now, don't bother backing up your data.

Sheesh.


Comment #4 by: Mark00 on 28 Oct 2009, 03:03 UTC reply to this comment

I find it interesting how many people and news outlets jumped on the apple hate wagon because of a very uncommon data loss bug while almost everyone fails to mention the install loop problem with Win7, the hardware trouble with Win7, the inconsistent run speed of Win7, the painfully slow updates to Win7, and games running slower on Win7 (which at least this author notes in the article as "some of the fuss").
It baffles me how so many call Snow Leopard a failure because of a single data-loss bug with uncommon conditions when back when I was running WindowsME I lost data on a monthly basis, and the only conditions necessary for that was turning on my computer. (I'm not saying that no one complained about ME, I just never heard those complaints on news sites).
Moreover, Apple has made mention of this bug and is fixing it. My past experience with Microsoft shows that they fail to mention their bugs till much later than they show up (i.e. they don't mention that their was a bug till they have a fix for it.)
I don't see it as nerve that they advertise instead of begging for apology and committing sepuku for their "heinous crime of having a data loss bug" as some seem to desire.


Comment #5 by: Stillwater on 28 Oct 2009, 03:12 UTC reply to this comment

If you believe that apple shouldn't advertise their OS until after their bug is fixed, do you also believe that Microsoft shouldn't advertise their OS until after all their bugs are fixed? Because then Microsoft could never advertise.

Copyright © 2001-2012 Softpedia. Contact/Tip us at

WindowsGamesDriversMacLinuxScriptsMobileHandheldNews

SUBMIT PROGRAM   |   ADVERTISE   |   GET HELP   |   SEND US FEEDBACK   |   RSS FEEDS   |   UPDATE YOUR SOFTWARE   |   ROMANIAN FORUM