Softpedia
 

NEWS CATEGORIES:



NEWS ARCHIVE >>
SOFTPEDIA REVIEWS >>
MEET THE EDITORS >>
Home > News > Security

November 15th, 2008, 11:18 GMT · By

AVG Tags Adobe Flash Player as Malware

SHARE:

Adjust text size:


AVG faulty definitions tag Adobe Flash Player component as malware
Enlarge picture
Users of the popular AVG antivirus product reported on the company's support forum that an Adobe flash component had been detected as a generic password stealing Trojan. This was caused by a faulty definition file that was pushed to users on Friday and followed a similar incident that occurred earlier this week, when the product wrongly identified a Windows component as malware and "cleaned" it.

According to user reports, the antivirus identified the flashUtil10a.exe file as Trojan Horse PSW.Generic6.AQPD. The file is actually an Adobe Flash Player 10 utility, which is used to automatically check for updates and also see if the player has been properly installed. AVG has not commented on this new incident, but according to a forum moderator, the problem has been fixed. Other users reported that the problem only affected version 8 of the antivirus product, while users of version 7.5 did not encounter the issue. However, since this information was not confirmed by AVG officials, it should be treated as such.

This is the third time in a month and second time in only a few days when AVG issues bogus definition files. The first of the three incidents consisted of false positives on no less than five components of the popular ZoneAlarm firewall, claiming that the files were infected with Trojan Horse Agent_r.CX. "We did accidentally tag Check Point’s Zone Alarm as a trojan. The detection was out for approximately 7.5 hours. As soon as we were notified of the issue, it was resolved and added to our whitelist," said an AVG spokeswoman at the time.

The second incident was more serious because it involved a vital Windows component, user32.dll. This file, which is otherwise known as the Windows User API Client DLL, stores instructions for graphical elements such as dialog boxes and windows. By removing the file, AVG rendered the users' systems unbootable. Fortunately, the issue only affected the Dutch, French, Italian, Portuguese, and Spanish language versions of Windows XP Professional. The company compensated the users affected by the user32.dll issue with a free one-year license extension and apologized by saying that "it sincerely regrets the inconvenience users have experienced."

Such false positives being caused by bugs in definition files are not an uncommon thing. Most vendors have been affected by them at one point or another, some even recently. They are certainly more serious when they involve vital operating system components, but blocking other third-party popular applications is at least annoying for many users. Even so, three such incidents in a month is more than what should be acceptable and this should prompt AVG to take a closer look at their quality assurance policies or the people who are responsible for implementing them.

TELL US WHAT YOU THINK:

8,393 hits · 7 comments · Link to this article · Print article · Send to friend · Subscribe to news

MUST-READ RELATED ARTICLES:


AVG Faulty Update Renders Computers Unbootable

AVG Detects ZoneAlarm as Trojan

McAfee Faulty Definitions Update Quarantine Vista Components

Trend Micro Antivirus Definitions Crash Computers

Anti-Virus Analysts Team Up in Criticizing Secunia Comparative Test

READER COMMENTS:


Comment #1 by: Ranan on 15 Nov 2008, 16:12 UTC reply to this comment

I agree with what I red just now and I want to inform the editor that I was using AVG free when I start to setup Ashampoo Magical Optimizer and the AVG 8 free eddition reported as Trojan Downloader although I downlod the ashampoo Magical optimizer from softpedia.com and when I saw the editor rating for AVG 8 free ( three stars out of five )and from that time I am not using it and I was surprized how this Antivirus regarded as softpedia pick and not the bitdefender for example that Iam using since then and I am very satisfied with it thank you for your time and Iam waiting for your opinion


Comment #2 by: james w allen on 15 Nov 2008, 16:27 UTC reply to this comment

Great!!! Keep up the good work! Its nice to be informed.


Comment #3 by: BrainBUG on 16 Nov 2008, 13:14 UTC reply to this comment

That's a quite a useful lesson for AV companies who make these faults, and ultimately the users are affected.


Comment #4 by: Lucian Constantin on 17 Nov 2008, 09:19 UTC reply to this comment

Hello,

Regarding the AVG review, it was done on version 7.1 and is over two years old, even if the award appears on the Softpedia product page of what is now AVG Free version 8. That review might no longer entirely reflect the quality of the current version 8. In addition, a lot of users consider AVG version 7.5 being better that version 8 for several reasons. Whether that is true on not, only you as a user can decide.

Regarding the comparison to BitDefender, we can't really make one, since you're talking about the AVG FREE version. Only the free version of AVG has the Softpedia Pick so if we are to make a comparison we should put it against other free solutions, such as Avira AntiVir Personal, which also has the Softpedia Pick and a Editor's review rating of 4 (out of 5) or Avast! Home Edition, which has a Editor's review rating of 5 (out of 5).

This should illustrate the fact that the testers or reviewers don't necessarily consider AVG as THE best antivirus solution. On the other hand, while these last few false positives were unfortunate incidents, it doesn't mean that AVG is a bad product. As i said in the article, other vendors had similar problems, but yes, this should sound the alarm for AVG that their quality assurance is not peachy.


Comment #5 by: PJ on 13 Dec 2008, 05:23 UTC reply to this comment

Paaah! I've encountered a half dozen instances of AVG 8.0 running F/P's for a number of programs; screensavers; add-ons and what have you. In one case the update to fix one F/P caused yet another. Despite my having to deal with terrified people to whom I've (sadly and mistakenly) recommended AVG 8.0 and called me wondering what to do about "all these infections", AVG hasn't done jack sh-t for me. They've already lost licenses as I'm now recommending ANYTHING else other than AVG False Positive Creator 8.0


Comment #6 by: maniacus on 13 Dec 2008, 16:53 UTC reply to this comment

Is there a fix to this? I was not hit by it, but my mother (850 miles away) was. Since I can not sit at her computer to fix this, is there an easy method I can explain to her over the phone?


Comment #7 by: Lucian Constantin on 15 Dec 2008, 07:32 UTC reply to this comment

@maniacus

Which of the three incidents mentioned in the article affected your mother's computer? There are different resolutions for each one of them obviously.

The Flash player one should be rather simple to deal with. Uninstall Flash Player plugin using Add/Remove Programs from Control Panel. Go to the Adobe main website and hit the Install Flash Player button. Then it should be straight forward.

The ZoneAlarm incident should also be easy to fix. Just update the AVG definitions and restore the files from AVG quarantine.

The user32.dll one is harder to fix, especially for non-technical users. So, i guess it depends on how much of the instructions your mother would be able to follow over the phone. It involves booting from the windows installation cd and entering the recovery console (command line), or creating a special boot cd from an image provided by AVG.

resolution 1: http://www.avg.com/faq.num-1574#faq_1574
resolution 2: http://www.avg.com/faq.num-1575#faq_1575

Good luck. Hope you succeed.

Copyright © 2001-2012 Softpedia. Contact/Tip us at

WindowsGamesDriversMacLinuxScriptsMobileHandheldNews

SUBMIT PROGRAM   |   ADVERTISE   |   GET HELP   |   SEND US FEEDBACK   |   RSS FEEDS   |   UPDATE YOUR SOFTWARE   |   ROMANIAN FORUM